Here atBaystate Insurance Group (BIG), we are a full-service Insurance Agency representing 20+ companies competing for the best rates for our customers.
Our job is to find the best fit with service and price, and to deliver on the promise that Baystate Insurance Group (BIG) will be the last call you ever make when shopping ALL of your insurance needs!
Assessing Your Needs
At Baystate Insurance Group (BIG), we help our communities with Home, Auto, Life and all other Insurance needs. We are independently-owned and operated, which means you are not obligated to use any one insurance carrier.
Your insurance needs may change but, with us, your agent doesn't also have to each time!
Building Relationships
By assisting our clients in servicing their policies, we are able to save them from spending valuable time waiting on hold with insurance companies only to speak to a stranger each time they need to make a small change.
This is where we come in and take care of it for you at your request, thus allowing you to do what you love to do most!
Nick began his Insurance career in 2016. He began as a Captive Agent and Trusted Advisor at Allstate Insurance. then moved on to oversee California's entire market for Mechanical Breakdown Insurance. He then is now the Agency Owner at Baystate Insurance, assisting with Agency Growth and Development.
Stephen Jones
Licensed Insurance Specialist
Personal Lines Coverage Specialist (PLCS)
Steve Jones joined Baystate Insurance Group as a Producer, bringing a strong background in customer service and digital marketing. A 2019 graduate of St. Mary’s College of Maryland and former captain of the men’s lacrosse team, Steve is dedicated to helping clients protect what matters most. Outside of work, he enjoys performing music locally, both as a solo artist and with his band.
Natalie Forgrave
Licensed Insurance Specialist
Personal & Commercial Lines Coverages Specialist
Natalie Forgrave began her insurance career several years ago and has built a strong reputation as a Personal and Commercial insurance expert. She takes pride in tailoring coverage to fit each client’s unique needs, ensuring they receive the best protection at the best value. Natalie is committed to making insurance simple and stress-fre
Natalie Forgrave began her insurance career several years ago and has built a strong reputation as a Personal and Commercial insurance expert. She takes pride in tailoring coverage to fit each client’s unique needs, ensuring they receive the best protection at the best value. Natalie is committed to making insurance simple and stress-free. Outside of work, she enjoys spending time with her family, or time at their family business, the Bogey Club Golf Lounge!
Lucas Collender
Licensed Insurance Specialist
Baystate Insurance Group
Lucas Collender began his insurance career in 2025 and quickly became known for his dedication to client service and practical, solution-focused guidance. With a strong background in the mortgage industry, he brings valuable insight into protecting clients’ homes, assets, and long-term financial goals. Lucas takes pride in making insuran
Lucas Collender began his insurance career in 2025 and quickly became known for his dedication to client service and practical, solution-focused guidance. With a strong background in the mortgage industry, he brings valuable insight into protecting clients’ homes, assets, and long-term financial goals. Lucas takes pride in making insurance clear, personalized, and easy to understand. Outside of work, you’ll often find him on the golf course or enjoying time with friends and family.
Jeffrey K. Nengel
Agency Consultant
Baystate Insurance Group
Jeff began his career in insurance in 1991 as a Life, Group Health and Benefits Specialist. He grew his practice to include Property and Casualty as well in the following years. He then ventured into his own Agency with Baystate Insurance Group with Nick, growing Baystate into what it is today.
Send Us Your Insurance Information Safely & Securely
Send Us Your Insurance Information Safely & Securely
Send Us Your Insurance Information Safely & Securely
Send Us Your Insurance Information Safely & Securely
Send Us Your Insurance Information Safely & Securely
Send Us Your Insurance Information Safely & Securely
Click below if you're ready to find the coverage that's right for you!
Baystate Insurance Group
1301 York Road, Suite 205, Lutherville Timonium, Maryland 21093, United States
Hours
Today
Closed
Social
Frequently Asked Questions
Please contact us if you cannot find an answer to your question.
A deductible is an amount that you're responsible for in the event of a loss. This is the amount you pay out-of-pocket, and insurance covers the remainder.
When speaking with your agent to set up your policy, any valuables you are concerned about and our agent can review your policy and recommend changes to ensure your valuables have proper coverage.
No. You do not need a new home appraisal during the renewal or coverage change process.
You Will Get All You Want in Life, If You Help Enough Other People Get What They Want.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.